Sale of a Database in Enforcement Proceedings May Be Compatible with GDPR, Even Without Explicit Consent
In a recent development in CJEU case no. C-693/22, Advocate General (GA) Priit Pikamäe expressed his opinion on the sale of a database during enforcement proceedings. The case originated from a Polish court and revolves around the sale of a database containing personal data, even in the absence of explicit consent from the data subjects.
Key Takeaways:
- The dispute involves a company and a board member from another company. The solvency of the debtor company is under question, with the board member arguing that the company’s assets, including two databases of user data, demonstrate solvency.
- The Polish court is seeking clarification from the ECJ on whether the sale of these databases by a bailiff in enforcement proceedings aligns with GDPR, given the lack of user consent for third-party data disclosure.
- GA Pikamäe suggests the ECJ should agree with the sale. He considers the bailiff’s actions of estimating and auctioning the databases as data processing under GDPR, with the bailiff being the controller of this processing.
- The GA argues that this data processing is lawful if it’s necessary for the execution of a task entrusted to the judicial officer as part of official authority.
- Pikamäe emphasizes the need for a balance between the creditor company’s property rights and the user’s right to personal data protection when assessing proportionality.
- According to Pikamäe, enforcing civil claims could potentially justify the data processing in question.
This opinion brings an interesting perspective on the intersection of data protection laws and enforcement proceedings. It highlights the need for careful consideration of all stakeholder rights in the digital age.
#DataPrivacy