The Legality of Cold Calling
Engaging potential customers without a prior business relationship, often referred to as cold calling, raises several questions from a data protection and competition law perspective.
In Germany, alongside the GDPR, the Act Against Unfair Competition (UWG - Gesetz gegen den unlauteren Wettbewerb) provides specific guidelines for advertising measures. The UWG is a national law influenced by various EU directives related to unfair commercial practices and advertising.
The GDPR defines advertising broadly, including customer satisfaction inquiries, birthday and Christmas mailings, and unsolicited recommendation emails. The basis for assessing legality can be either Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR or consent under Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR.
Email Acquisition
Generally, the recipient’s consent is required for sending promotional emails unless the information was requested by the recipient. Unsolicited advertising via email can be considered an unreasonable nuisance in both B2B and B2C sectors. However, there is an exception if: 1) The advertiser has received the recipient’s email address in connection with the sale of a product or service. 2) The advertiser uses the address for direct advertising of similar products or services. 3) The recipient has not objected to the use of their email address. 4) The recipient is clearly informed at the time of data collection and each subsequent use that they can object to the use of their email address at any time without incurring any costs beyond the basic transmission rates.
Telephone Acquisition
In the B2B sector, telephone contact can be permissible under certain conditions, such as a “factual interest based on specific circumstances” suggesting that the recipient would agree to the call. For B2C contacts, explicit prior consent is always required.
While the principles described here are based on German law, similar rules apply across other EU countries due to the harmonization efforts of the GDPR and EU directives. However, each country may have its own specific laws and regulations that implement and interpret these directives (i.e., Italy and France with their stricter rules).