A EUR 4.3 million expensive Case Study in Compliance Failure
The recent decision by the Polish Data Protection Authority (UODO) underscores a critical compliance lesson for financial institutions: scanning identity documents must be preceded by a legitimate purpose and risk assessment.
Between 1 April 2019 and 23 September 2020, ING Bank Śląski scanned ID cards of customers and potential customers without conducting an appropriate expediency analysis. This included cases unrelated to Act on Counteracting Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing (AML) requirements (such as complaint handling) where such data processing was unnecessary.
UODO conducted an inspection. Key Findings: The bank failed to assess whether scanning was necessary under the AML. Identity documents were scanned without an individual risk assessment, violating the risk-based approach mandated by AML regulations. The practice affected a large volume of personal data, including PESEL numbers, names, and document details—posing a high risk of identity theft and fraud.
The result? A record PLN 18.4 million (EUR 4.3 million) fine imposed due to violation of GDPR Articles 5(1)(a), (b), (c) and 6(1) due to unjustified processing.
What now?
1) Conduct purposefulness and necessity analyses before collecting sensitive data.
2) Align internal procedures with legal obligations, not convenience.
3) Ensure transparency and accountability in data handling.