CJEU defines personal data through the lens of the controller and not the recipient

← Alle Beiträge
Datenschutz · EN

CJEU defines personal data through the lens of the controller and not the recipient

In today’s judgment in Case C-413/23 P (EDPS v SRB), the Court of Justice of the European Union clarified the scope of “personal data” under Regulation 2018/1725 in the context of pseudonymised data transfers.

The case concerned the SRB’s transmission of pseudonymised comments from affected shareholders and creditors to Deloitte, without prior notice. The EDPS had found this to be a breach of the information obligation. The General Court disagreed, but the CJEU has now overturned that decision.

My key takeaways from the press release (ruling not yet published):

1) Personal opinions are inherently personal data: The Court held that expressions of personal views are intrinsically linked to their authors. Their identifiable nature does not require further analysis of content, purpose, or effect.
2) Pseudonymised data is not always personal data: The Court confirmed that pseudonymisation can render data anonymous for third parties, depending on context. Identifiability must be assessed case-by-case, based on who holds the means of re-identification (Breyer case) .
3) Information obligations depend on the controller’s perspective: The obligation to inform data subjects applies at the point of data collection and must be assessed from the controller’s viewpoint—not the recipient’s. Whether the recipient (here: Deloitte) could identify the data subject is irrelevant.

This ruling reinforces a controller-centric approach to data protection and underscores the importance of context in assessing identifiability.

Zu diesem Beitrag gibt es auf LinkedIn ein Dokument als Anhang. Auf LinkedIn ansehen →

Auf LinkedIn diskutieren