Personal Data ≠ Payment: German Court Interprets EU Consumer Law

← Alle Beiträge
Datenschutz · EN

Personal Data ≠ Payment: German Court Interprets EU Consumer Law

A recent decision by the Higher Regional Court of Stuttgart (Germany) covers the legal boundaries of “paying with data” in consumer contracts.
The case concerned a loyalty programme (“Lidl Plus”) that offers personalised discounts and benefits in exchange for user registration and the provision of personal data (e.g. name, date of birth, email). The programme was advertised as “free of charge.” A consumer protection association challenged this, arguing that the data provided constitutes a form of payment and must be disclosed as such under consumer protection law.

The court rejected this argument. It held that under German law – aligned with the Digital Content Directive (EU Directive 2019/770) and the Consumer Rights Directive (Directive 2011/83/EU) – the term “price” refers exclusively to monetary payment or digital representations of value. Personal data does not qualify as a “price” in the legal sense. Therefore, the provider was not required to disclose the data exchange as a form of payment under the relevant consumer information obligations.

The court also found that describing the programme as “free” was not misleading. The data processing was transparently disclosed in the terms of participation, and no monetary cost was incurred by the consumer. The requirements of German competition law were not violated.

However, the judgment reaffirms that companies offering digital services in exchange for personal data remain subject to extensive legal obligations under the GDPR, including:

1) Clear and specific information on data usage (e.g. tracking, advertising)
2) Valid and informed consent
3) Right of withdrawal
4) Data deletion protocols post-contract

The claimant has announced plans to pursue further judicial review, potentially before Germany’s Federal Court of Justice.

What’s the Legal Position Where You Are?

Zu diesem Beitrag gibt es auf LinkedIn ein Bild. Auf LinkedIn ansehen →

Auf LinkedIn diskutieren