Access Rights in Employment – High Threshold for GDPR Damages Claims
The Labour Court of Heilbronn/Germany (Judgment of 27 March 2025, Ref. 8 Ca 123/24) has clarified an important point:
A breach of the right of access under Article 15 GDPR does not automatically trigger a claim for damages under Article 82 GDPR.
Key takeaways from the decision:
1) Duty to specify requests: In long-term employment relationships involving large volumes of data, employees must narrow down their access requests (see Recital 63 GDPR).
2) Purpose limitation: The right of access is designed to allow individuals to verify the lawfulness of processing, not to gather evidence for unrelated claims (e.g., overtime pay).
3) Causation requirement: To claim damages, there must be a proven causal link between the infringement and the alleged harm. Mere fears or speculative risks are insufficient (cf. CJEU, C‑487/21).
Bottom line: Article 15 GDPR is not a universal tool for litigation strategy. Employers should still respond diligently to access requests, but courts are setting clear boundaries on how these rights can be used.