How to not get paid for an Expert Opinion
An expert in Germany who used AI extensively in preparing a court report without disclosing it saw his fee reduced to €0. Similar legal consequences should apply in other jurisdictions where expert evidence requires personal authorship and integrity.
Reasoning of the German court to reduce the fee:
1) Failure to declare AI use and lack of personal authorship violated procedural duties (Legal Basis: §§ 4 JVEG, 407a ZPO, 8a JVEG).
T2) The report was deemed unusable: no personal examination, factual errors, and strong indicators of AI-generated text.
3) Transparency and accountability are essential in expert opinions.
Here are some indicators for the court that AI was used to generate the report:
“Indicators include the overall style of writing: the expert lists himself with full address as the recipient of the order, repeats the same phrase three times, and uses almost exclusively main clauses with identical sentence beginnings – all typical AI patterns.” (translated from German)
Takeaways:
1) If you use AI, verify everything.
2) Be transparent about AI involvement.
3) If you cheat, you don’t get paid.
How should courts and professionals balance efficiency through AI with the need for accountability and trust?
Source: District Court Darmstadt; Decision of 10.11.2025, 19 O 527/16