German Court: US Is Still Considered a Democracy, Refusing Art. 15 Information on US…

← Alle Beiträge
Datenschutz · EN

German Court: US Is Still Considered a Democracy, Refusing Art. 15 Information on US Agency Access Is Lawful

The recent judgment of the Regional Court of Bonn/Germany (LG Bonn, 03 June 2025 – 13 O 156/24) stands out for its unusually clear assessment of the structural incompatibilities between US surveillance law and the GDPR. The Court openly acknowledges that US federal law (in particular Section 702 FISA) creates a transparency deficit that fundamentally conflicts with Art. 15 GDPR.

The service provider sits in an unavoidable duty conflict:

EU law obliges disclosure <=> US law prohibits disclosure.

The Court emphasises that this justification is only available because the United States is still considered a democratic state governed by the rule of law. Had the Court classified the US legal system as falling below that threshold, such a justification would not have been possible.

From a GDPR perspective, three points are essential:

1) Transfers to the US remain lawful: After 10 July 2023 under the EU‑US Data Privacy Framework (Art. 45 GDPR), and before that under Art. 49(1)(b) GDPR based on contractual necessity.
2) No Art. 15 GDPR right to know whether US agencies accessed the data
Not because of Art. 15(4) GDPR or § 29 BDSG (the Court rejects both), but solely due to the unavoidable duty conflict arising from mandatory US secrecy obligations.
3) No Art. 82 GDPR damages: The claimant failed to show any concrete harm or plausible negative consequences linked to a hypothetical intelligence access.

The decision is a clear reminder of the unresolved structural tension between EU fundamental rights and foreign surveillance regimes. It also confirms that duty‑conflict reasoning may play a growing role in EU‑US data transfer cases, even where the underlying democratic legitimacy of the target jurisdiction is already under judicial scrutiny.

The uploaded image contains an unofficial English translation (abridged) from the judgment.

Zu diesem Beitrag gibt es auf LinkedIn ein Bild. Auf LinkedIn ansehen →

Auf LinkedIn diskutieren