The CJEU’s NTH Haustechnik judgment is more than just a ruling on multiple legal bases under the GDPR
Much of the attention surrounding the CJEU’s judgment in Case C-484/24 (NTH Haustechnik GmbH, 18 June 2026) has focused on one important clarification: a controller may, under certain circumstances, rely on more than one legal basis under Article 6(1) GDPR for the same processing activity.
That point alone resolves a long-running debate in privacy practice. However, the judgment has considerably more to offer:
1) Article 17(3)(e) GDPR is not a standalone authorisation to process data
The exemption from the right to erasure for the establishment, exercise or defence of legal claims does not replace the need for a valid legal basis under Article 6(1) GDPR.
2) GDPR violations do not automatically make evidence inadmissible
The Court confirmed that the GDPR does not create an absolute prohibition on the use of evidence that was obtained in breach of data protection requirements. Courts must instead perform a proportionality assessment and ensure that any disclosure of personal data remains limited to what is necessary.
3) Transparency failures do not automatically trigger an exclusion of evidence
A failure to comply with Article 13 GDPR does not, by itself, prevent a court from considering the relevant information.
The judgment is worth reading not only for its clarification on Article 6 GDPR, but also for its broader guidance on the interaction between data protection, evidence and access to justice.