Are You Using Cookie Paywalls On Your Website?

← All articles
Data protection · EN

Are You Using Cookie Paywalls On Your Website?

In November, Meta introduced a paid version of Facebook and Instagram in Europe, and many websites, especially those with journalistic content, now provide users with a choice: access content for free with extensive tracking or pay a fee to opt out of web analysis known as “Pur-Subscription Models” or “Cookie Paywalls”. This post explores their GDPR compliance and outlines conditions for their implementation (according to the Datenschutzkonferenz (DSK), the body of independent German data protection supervisory authorities at federal and state level).

I. Pur-Subscription Models: Payment for Informational Self-Determination

“Pur-Subscription Models,” or “Cookie Paywalls,” popular on news and knowledge-sharing sites, generate revenue and compensate authors. Users choose between free access with tracking or paid browsing without behavior analysis, with a banner prompting a decision on page load.

II. Data Protection Compliance of Pur-Subscription Models

Past debates questioned the voluntariness of tracking consent for free usage. On March 22, 2023, the DSK declared Pur-Subscription Models legally permissible under specific conditions. Note: DSK decisions, while not legally binding, hold practical significance in legal evaluations.

III. Conditions for Data Protection-Compliant Pur-Subscription Models
According to the DSK:

1. Equivalence: Paid models must offer content equivalent to free models with tracking consent.
2. Informed Consent for Tracking: Transparent consent in the free model, referencing the privacy policy.
3. Granularity of Consent: No general consents; users must actively choose specific purposes.
4. Necessary Operations in Pur-Mode: Information storage in the paid model only when essential for website operation.

IV. Conclusion
Users can choose between free tracking and paid tracking protection with Pur-Subscription Models. The DSK has established conditions for compliant operation, highlighting the importance of granular consents. Additionally, other processing purposes, such as newsletter delivery, push notifications, or retargeting, must remain voluntary.

Attached is the decision of the DSK. The original is only available in English, so I had it translated using Deepl. Please keep this in mind when reading.

#DataProtection #PurSubscriptionModels #Meta #CookiePaywalls

This post has a document attached on LinkedIn. View on LinkedIn →

Discuss on LinkedIn