Upcoming Cases in Germany on Data Scraping Damages

← All articles
Data protection · EN

Upcoming Cases in Germany on Data Scraping Damages

Mark your calendar: On October 8, 2024, the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) in Germany will hear two pivotal cases (VI ZR 7/24 and VI ZR 22/24) concerning compensation claims for individuals whose data was illicitly scraped and disseminated online by unknown third parties.

In both cases, the defendant is Facebook (Meta Platforms, Inc.). The incidents stem from a major data breach in April 2021, where information from approximately 533 million Facebook users across 106 countries was leaked online. This breach was facilitated by a feature that allowed Facebook profiles to be found via phone numbers, which third parties exploited using automated scraping tools.

The plaintiffs, whose user IDs, names, countries, and genders were exposed, seek compensation for non-material damages, alleging insufficient security measures by Facebook. They report experiencing anxiety, stress, and loss of comfort and time. Additionally, they demand an injunction and information disclosure.

Previous rulings saw the Heilbronn and Cologne Regional Courts dismiss the claims, but the Stuttgart and Cologne Higher Regional Courts provided mixed outcomes. The Stuttgart Higher Regional Court partially upheld one plaintiff’s appeal, recognizing Facebook’s liability for future damages, while the Cologne Higher Regional Court upheld the dismissal. Both plaintiffs are now pursuing their claims through BGH-approved revisions.

The outcomes could set significant precedents in data protection law.

#DataProtection #Facebook

This post has an image on LinkedIn. View on LinkedIn →

Discuss on LinkedIn