In September 2022, the European Commission proposed a directive on AI civil liability (AILD) with an impact assessment. The European Parliament’s Committee on Legal Affairs (JURI) requested a further assessment, revealing shortcomings like incomplete policy exploration and limited cost-benefit analysis of the strict liability regime. The study suggests expanding AILD to cover general-purpose and ‘high-impact AI systems’ and software. It recommends a mixed liability framework and transitioning from an AI-focused directive to a software liability regulation to avoid market fragmentation and enhance clarity across the EU.