Avoid Redaction Pitfalls: How to Protect Personal Data Under GDPR
Handling data access requests under Article 15(3) GDPR often leaves data controllers pondering how to redact third-party personal data from documents effectively.
Errors in redaction can lead to breaches of third-party privacy and potentially reportable data breaches under Article 33 GDPR. Here are some key strategies to consider:
1. Digital Redaction:
- Ensure redactions are both visual and technical.
- Create a backup before editing.
- Familiarize yourself with the redaction tool to ensure it offers true technical redaction.
- Be cautious with tools requiring document uploads, as they may pose data protection risks. Always check the software provider’s data handling practices and, if necessary, establish a data processing agreement under Article 28(3) GDPR.
2. Manual Redaction:
- If digital tools are unavailable, print and manually redact documents, then scan them back if an electronic format is needed.
- Ensure the ink used for redaction makes the text completely illegible, even under light or with contrast adjustments.
3. Redaction of Photos:
- Prefer irreversible redaction over pixelation or resolution reduction, as AI can often reconstruct pixelated images.
- Save edited images in formats that prevent the recovery of the original version.
4. Metadata:
- Don’t forget to redact metadata, which can contain personal information like authorship and modification dates.
- Convert Word documents to PDF to remove change histories, or copy anonymized text into a new file if an editable version is required.
📜 Historical Example 📜
To illustrate the importance of effective redaction, consider the case of “Biographic Data: Gen Augusto Pinochet Ugarte,” from January 1975. This Defense Intelligence Agency bio sketch describes the Chilean dictator. The full version released in 1999 included details like his preference for Pisco Sours. However, censors decided in 2003 to excise such information.
There are various ways to redact documents in compliance with GDPR, but the goal is always the same: ensure that redacted personal data cannot be read or reconstructed. Regularly review your redaction processes and educate your staff on best practices.