Are You at Risk of Paying Twice?

← All articles
Data protection · EN

Are You at Risk of Paying Twice?

Today, I want to go back to 2 recent court rulings in Germany regarding encryption and data protection.

Key Takeaways from the Court Decisions

1. OLG Schleswig-Holstein Decision (2024) (B2C; GDPR applied):

  - The court ruled that a payment made by a customer to a third party’s account, due to unauthorized changes made to an invoice sent by email, does not fulfill the payment obligation under § 362(2) BGB. However, the customer can try to invoke a counterclaim for damages under Article 82(2) of the GDPR against the contractor in case of insufficient data protection measures as required by Art. 5, 24 and 32 GDPR.
  - The court emphasized that mere transport encryption (like TLS) is inadequate for protecting sensitive data. For sensitive information, end-to-end encryption is considered necessary, reflecting the heightened standards imposed by the GDPR.

2. OLG Karlsruhe Decision (2023) (B2B; GDPR not applied):

  - The court stated that there are no specific legal requirements for security measures when sending emails in pure commercial transactions without PII. The nature and extent of necessary security measures should be determined by the reasonable security expectations within the relevant industry.
  - If a creditor fails to implement sufficient security measures resulting in a payment being made to a fraudulent account, the creditor may still retain the right to claim the owed amount. However, the debtor may counterclaim for damages if there was a breach of security obligations. However, prooving this could be difficult.

Practical Advice for Businesses

For Sellers: Implement Strong Security Measures: For invoices (at least of significant value), it is crucial to protect them with end-to-end encryption or at least use a strong password for the zipped PDF-file.

For Buyers: Verify Payment Details: Always double-check the bank details before making any payments, especially if you receive revised invoices. Contact the seller directly through known channels if you notice discrepancies.

OLG Schleswig-Holstein, Judgment of December 18, 2024 – Az.: 12 U 9/24
OLG Karlsruhe, Judgment of July 27, 2023 – Az.: 19 U 83/22

This post has an image on LinkedIn. View on LinkedIn →

Discuss on LinkedIn