What Do Gold Teeth Have to Do with the GDPR?
Recently, I came across a decision from early 2025 again. A case that actually dates back to the early years of the GDPR and still illustrates a fundamental principle of EU data protection law (case Germany’s Federal Administrative Court (BVerwG) 29.01.2025 - 6 C 3.23).
The dispute began in 2017, before the GDPR took effect, when a company collected phone numbers of dental practices from public directories and used them for unsolicited marketing calls to buy old dental gold. After the GDPR became applicable in May 2018, the company argued that the new legal framework allowed a fresh balancing under legitimate interests.
In January 2025, the Court finally clarified the matter: a company cold‑calling dentists for gold‑purchasing purposes cannot rely on “legitimate interests” under Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR.
The Court highlighted that unsolicited advertising calls already violate national unfair‑competition law (UWG), which implements EU rules on unwanted communications. Interpreting the GDPR to permit such calls would undermine the coherence of EU law.
And crucially: A publicly listed phone number does not imply consent to marketing calls. Its purpose is to enable patient contact, not to facilitate commercial outreach by third parties.
Why this still matters today:
1) Publicly available data is not a green light for marketing.
2) “Legitimate interest” is not a rescue clause for unsolicited outreach.
3) GDPR and sector‑specific marketing rules must be assessed together.