Access Rights Under Article 15 GDPR – Pending CJEU Cases

← All articles
Data protection · EN

Access Rights Under Article 15 GDPR – Pending CJEU Cases

Access rights remain one of the most litigated areas of EU data protection law. Here is a series of pending preliminary references to the CJEU:

1) “Copy of personal data” vs. full documents: (C‑676/25, Viva Credit): Does Art. 15(3) GDPR require disclosure of entire contracts (e.g. loan agreements) where processing is limited to AML archiving, including where the data subject already holds the contract?
2) Interplay of access and data portability: Can Article 20 GDPR be used to obtain full contractual documentation post‑termination, where data is retained solely for regulatory purposes?
3) Transparency vs. data minimisation: How do Art. 5(1)(a), (c), (d) GDPR constrain access and portability rights, particularly where contracts were concluded following algorithmic profiling / ML‑based assessments?
4) Limits, proportionality and judicial review: Multiple cases address when controllers may limit or refuse access, including: “excessive” or abusive requests (C‑526/24, Brillen Rottler), requests allegedly aimed at provoking damages claims, claims that contractual clauses fall outside Art. 15 scope, and national rules excluding access to supervisory authority files (C‑205/25, BayLDA).
5) Supervisory authorities as controllers: Can a DPA become a “controller” under Art. 15 GDPR when handling complaints under Art. 77 GDPR?
6) “Source of data” and third‑party interests (C‑185/25, Waldfelber): Does Art. 15(1)(g) extend to unnamed conversational sources, and how must courts balance this against third‑party expectations?
7) Access rights and non‑material damages: What is the threshold for Art. 82 GDPR: is loss of control / uncertainty sufficient, or must damage be causally linked to a distinct processing operation?

Bottom line: These cases will define the operational limits of DSARs, especially for financial services, AML retention, public authorities and mass‑litigation scenarios.

This post has an image on LinkedIn. View on LinkedIn →

Discuss on LinkedIn