Italy: €17.6 million GDPR fine for unlawful customer data transfer

← All articles
Data protection · EN

Italy: €17.6 million GDPR fine for unlawful customer data transfer

On 12 March 2026, the Italian Data Protection Authority (Garante per la protezione dei dati personali) imposed a €17.6 million fine on Intesa Sanpaolo S.p.A. for GDPR violations linked to the transfer of customer data to its digital subsidiary Isybank.

The case is based on a large‑scale internal restructuring project. Intesa Sanpaolo positioned Isybank as part of its digital transformation strategy and transferred selected customer segments to the new digital bank. Around 2.4 million customers were affected.

The key legal issue: whether the upstream selection of customers constituted profiling under Art. 4(4) GDPR and, if so, whether it could be justified by legitimate interests or required consent.

Intesa argued that it merely filtered customers using objective criteria, without automated evaluation of personal aspects and without marketing intentions. The authority disagreed. According to the Garante, customers were selected based on criteria such as age, asset status, usage behaviour and digital preferences, which amounts to profiling. Crucially, this profiling occurred before the transfer and therefore required its own legal basis.

The authority found that:

1) reliance on legitimate interest failed due to an insufficient balancing test and inadequate consideration of customer expectations;
2) consent under Art. 6(1)(a) GDPR would have been required for the profiling step;
3) transparency and information duties were breached: information was embedded in a marketing context, provided only via online banking inboxes, and delivered during a period of low attention (summer holidays);
4) an opt‑out mechanism was used, which many customers never effectively noticed, undermining informed decision‑making.

As a result, the Garante identified violations of Art. 5(1)(a), Art. 6(1) and Art. 14 GDPR, assessed as serious rather than minor. Mitigating factors included negligent (not intentional) conduct, cooperation with the authority, and remedial measures taken in parallel proceedings before the competition authority.

Intesa Sanpaolo may close the case by paying half of the fine within 30 days.

Internal restructurings and data migrations are not GDPR‑neutral. Even where no external disclosure occurs, profiling is a separate processing operation requiring clear legal justification and meaningful transparency. Digital transformation does not lower the GDPR bar.

Source translated with deepl. Read with care.

This post has a document attached on LinkedIn. View on LinkedIn →

Discuss on LinkedIn