Help me out: Can lawyers, doctors, psychotherapists, pharmacists and other regulated…

← All articles
Artificial intelligence · EN

Help me out: Can lawyers, doctors, psychotherapists, pharmacists and other regulated professionalsactually use Claude for confidential client work?

I increasingly see articles saying that lawyers can use AI services such as Claude, provided they comply with professional secrecy, data protection and appropriate security requirements.

That sounds reassuring but it leaves the most important question unanswered: Can e.g., an ordinary law firm obtain the contractual commitments required by law? I am not talking about law firms the size of Freshfields.

Under section 43e of the German Federal Lawyers’ Act, a service provider that may access client secrets must be contractually bound to confidentiality in text form. The agreement must also address the criminal consequences of a breach, necessary access and the involvement of further persons.

A DPA, ISO certification, audit logs, retention controls and “no model training by default” do not automatically meet these requirements.

I have found no public confirmation that the standard terms for Claude Team or Claude Enterprise include a section 43e BRAO-compliant professional-secrecy addendum. You?

Large international firms may be able to negotiate such agreements. Freshfields has announced a multi-year cooperation with Anthropic and provides Claude through its own AI platform to 5,700 employees.
Smaller firms do not have that bargaining power.

Anthropic should provide a standard professional-secrecy addendum for regulated professions since professionals cannot assume that a standard AI subscription, a GDPR DPA or a “no training” statement is sufficient to protect information covered by national professional-secrecy laws.

This post has an image on LinkedIn. View on LinkedIn →

Discuss on LinkedIn